Seattle Family Calendar
Subscribe
Parents often ask me, “What’s the right thing to say?”
I understand why. Whether your child has lied, cheated, experimented with substances or faced heartbreaking news, as parents we want the perfect words. We imagine that if we can just find the right sentence, everything will fall into place.
After decades of working with families, I’ve come to a different conclusion. Hard conversations rarely succeed because of one brilliant sentence. They succeed because of how parents enter the conversation. When our emotions are running high, we naturally want to fix, reassure or correct. We move quickly toward our own agenda.
Children come to these conversations with different needs. Before they can truly connect with us, they need to feel secure. They need to know that you, as their parent, understand what the situation feels like to them. Meaningful guidance has a much better chance of taking root after children feel understood.
Parents often tell me, “I need to nip this in the bud.” I understand the impulse. But most significant parenting challenges are less about pruning a bad bud than tending a garden. Brave conversations enrich the soil. They strengthen trust and the parent-child relationship so that later conversations have fertile ground in which to grow.
The anatomy of a brave conversation
With topics like school problems, substance use, sibling conflict, mental health or another difficult topic, the content of the conversation changes. The underlying anatomy of a brave conversation does not. Before you begin, here are six considerations worth carrying into almost every difficult conversation.
Begin with yourself.
The first conversation is always the one you have with yourself. What emotions are you bringing into this moment: fear, anger, disappointment, urgency?
After calming yourself enough to get your heart rate down, you will be able to do what I call opening up your satellite dish. Like tuning into a wider universe within our brains, thinking about our values, goals, strategies and options expands our intelligence. It makes us wiser. We become better able to pull in everything we know about this particular child instead of reacting to the problem in front of us.
Your child lives in their own emotional world.
By the time you decide it’s time for the conversation, your child has often been living inside the emotional climate surrounding the issue for quite a while. They may have been struggling with a challenging temperament, wrestling with a friendship, wondering whether they disappointed you or feeling pulled by peers long before you knew there was a problem.
Before trying to influence your child, pause and imagine what it has been like to be them. What story might they be telling themselves about this situation?
Ask and listen with humble curiosity.
Children are the experts on what it feels like to be them. Ask questions that feel safe rather than threatening. “Help me understand,” “Tell me more,” and “What’s that been like for you?” are all great sentence starts you can use.
Listen longer than feels comfortable. Resist the urge to persuade, correct, defend your position or argue with your child’s experience. Your goal is understanding before influence.
Help your child feel understood.
Research on validation consistently shows that children become much more open to guidance after they feel seen and understood. Validation isn’t agreement or approval of a behavior; it conveys understanding of their emotional perspective.
“Given who you are and what you’ve been experiencing, I can understand why this feels the way it does.” Feeling understood lowers defensiveness. It helps children reflect out loud instead of protecting themselves from us.
Build for many more good conversations.
Children grow through many conversations, not one. Some conversations are about understanding. Others are about values, teaching, limits, problem-solving, agreements, monitoring or consequences. Resist the temptation to accomplish everything today. Good conversations don’t replace the rest of parenting. They prepare the ground for it. The relationship you strengthen today becomes the foundation for all the conversations that follow.
Leave the relationship stronger than before.
When the conversation ends, your child doesn’t have to agree with you. The problem doesn’t have to be solved. But if your child walks away feeling supported, understood, accepted and connected, you’ve accomplished something profoundly important.
Scenario: When the ‘harder kid’ begins to feel like the ‘bad kid’
Some family patterns develop so gradually that parents don’t recognize them until one day a child says something that stops them in their tracks: “You love Rachel more than me,” “You hate me,” or “What is wrong with me? I’m always in trouble.” Or from the “easier” sibling: “George gets all your attention,” or “It’s okay. George can have my turn. I can’t take another meltdown.”
These painful roles often emerge when one child comes into the world with a temperament that requires much more attention, coaching, supervision and emotional energy than another sibling. That child naturally receives more reminders, more correction, more limit-setting and more negative reactions simply because life is harder for them. The more adaptable sibling is praised for being patient, flexible, dependable and “so easy.” Parents don’t think of one child as “bad” and the other as “good.” But children notice patterns, and over time both begin drawing conclusions that no parent ever intended.
Sarah’s situation
Sarah (not her real name) came to see me after her 7-year-old son George burst into tears decrying her preference for his sister Rachel (the “easier” of the two). Sarah realized she wasn’t simply trying to help George manage his emotions anymore. She needed to change the stories both children were beginning to tell themselves about who they were in the family.
She reminded herself that George hadn’t chosen his temperament any more than another child chooses asthma, dyslexia, autism, ADHD or food allergies. He came into the world with a nervous system that ran hot. His powerful emotional engine made life harder for him, but it also fueled many of the qualities she treasured most: his curiosity, enthusiasm, creativity and wholehearted engagement with life.
Sarah reminded herself that Rachel’s adaptability was a blessing, but also a risk. Easy children can gradually become pleasers, learning that family harmony depends on asking for less than they need.
Her goal wasn’t to make George less intense or Rachel less of a pleaser. It was to help both children feel deeply understood and equally cherished.
Sarah’s approach
A few days later, Sarah had her opportunity. George exploded when his elaborate block city came crashing down and he hurled blocks across the room, striking Sarah. Without thinking, she snapped, “George! I’ve had it with you! I can’t take this anymore!” George froze. Then he screamed, “I hate myself! And you hate me too!”
Rachel stood silently in the doorway, then turned and walked back to her room. Sarah knew they would eventually have to talk again about throwing blocks and hurting people. But this wasn’t the right moment. Later Sarah found George sitting on the back steps. “Can you help me understand what happened for you?” George shrugged. Sarah waited. Finally he spoke.
“Everything was going so good. I wanted to build the biggest one ever. And then it fell apart.”
Sarah nodded. “You get so excited about things. You throw yourself into them with your whole heart. Then when something goes wrong, your feelings overflow. Sometimes I wonder what it’s like to have such a big engine inside you.”
“It goes too fast,” he said.
“It’s an engine that sometimes gets away from you. That’s where Dad and I come in. Our job is to help you learn how to drive it and put the brakes on earlier.”
Almost whispering, George said, “I hate my engine.”
“Oh, sweetheart, I love your engine. It will take a while before you learn to shift gears. That’s okay. We are all works in progress.”
Later that evening, Sarah talked with Rachel. “Sometimes it’s really hard having George for a brother.” Rachel nodded and said, “He gets all your time.”
“Sometimes he does,” Sarah acknowledged. “And I never want you to think that means your feelings matter less. I’m going to do a better job making sure we have time that’s just ours. And if I don’t, I want you to tell me. Your voice matters in this family.”
Sarah hadn’t solved George’s emotional intensity or erased Rachel’s frustration. She had done something just as important. She had begun changing the stories both children were telling themselves about who they are in their family, and she had made it more likely that the next hard conversation would begin with trust instead of fear.
Scenario: Finding a vape
A father I know has only one rule about difficult parenting conversations: Never have an important conversation during the first 10 minutes after you’ve entered the “red zone.”
Another mom Melissa (not her real name) learned this lesson the hard way. While doing laundry, she reached into the pocket of her 15-year-old daughter Tate’s jeans and pulled out a nicotine vape. Melissa had always known experimentation might happen someday. She just wasn’t prepared for “someday” to arrive this early.
Her first thought was immediate: I have to stop this. Then she paused. She took some deep breaths. She reminded herself of the considerations she wanted to carry into this conversation. She knew it wasn’t realistic to end Tate’s relationship with nicotine in an afternoon.
She reminded herself that Tate had always been a confident, novelty-seeking, adventurous kid. The very qualities that made her willing to organize scavenger hunts, invent elaborate games and enthusiastically try new things also made experimentation more tempting than it might be for another teenager.
Melissa knew she couldn’t change Tate’s temperament. She also knew what researchers have documented for years — that the combination of high authority along with warmth, responsiveness and supporting independence was the kind of parenting that results in positive outcomes for kids. So she chose the part of herself that Tate was more likely to talk to — the accepting, open and understanding part. The warmth and understanding would open the door, and the authoritative rules and guide rails could come later.
After Melissa told Tate she had found the vape and thrown it away, Tate immediately pushed back. “That was my friend’s, not mine. I can’t believe you threw it away! It’s no big deal. It wasn’t drugs.” Melissa could feel herself entering the red zone. Instead of continuing, she waited until the next day.
When they were both calmer, she sat down beside her daughter. “Before we talk about the vape, I want you to know something first. It’s been wonderful watching you blossom in high school. You’re adventurous, creative, funny and willing to try new things. We love you dearly. Finding this vape doesn’t change that.” Tate relaxed just a little, so Melissa continued. “Our hope is that you’ll choose not to vape or use other substances during high school because we care about your health and your future.”
Then Melissa asked the question she had practiced asking instead of launching into a lecture: “Help me understand what you like about vaping.”
Tate shrugged. “It kind of relaxes you. But it also gives you a little zing. It’s fun at parties.”
Everything inside Melissa wanted to explain nicotine addiction. Instead, she stayed curious. “What do you think the downsides are?”
“I guess … you could get addicted.”
“How much do your friends think about addiction when they’re vaping?”
Tate laughed. “Not much.”
Now they had something real to think about together. Melissa felt the familiar temptation to keep going. Instead, she stopped. They were ending the conversation feeling connected, and she wanted to quit while she was ahead. Melissa hadn’t solved vaping. That was unrealistic. She had done something just as important. She had made it more likely that Tate would continue thinking with her about the increasingly complicated decisions that lay ahead.
Scenario: Frenemies. When the friendship hurts, but your child won’t let go
Few things are harder than watching your child repeatedly get hurt by someone they desperately want to keep as a friend. Mom Denise (not her real name) described her dilemma this way. “My seventh-grade daughter, Cassy, comes home upset about Isabelle at least once a week. One day they’re inseparable. The next day Isabelle ignores her, excludes her or says something cutting in front of the other girls. Every time I think Cassy is finally done with this friendship, she goes right back.”
Denise realized she had two very different goals she could pursue: One was convincing Cassy to end the friendship. The other was helping Cassy become wiser about friendships. She chose the second.
Denise found Cassy reading in her room. “Can I start by apologizing for something? I think I’ve been too quick to focus on the parts of your friendship that worry me. That’s the mama bear in me. I hear how hurt you are, and I want to protect you. But I also know that isn’t the whole story. You have a lot of fun with Isabelle. You choose to spend time with her. I don’t think I’ve spent enough time understanding that part. So can we back up? I’d really like to hear about your best times with Isabelle. What do you enjoy most about being with her?”
Cassy smiled. “She’s hilarious. Everybody wants to be around her. She’s really confident. She’s always coming up with fun things to do. She’s just … exciting.”
“I can understand why you’d be drawn to someone like that. When you’re with Isabelle, when do you feel most like yourself?”
“When it’s just the two of us.”
“And when do you feel least like yourself?”
“When the other girls are there.”
“What changes?”
“I start worrying about saying something stupid.”
Denise let the silence do some work. “I’ve noticed something. Sometimes you come home from being with Isabelle happy and energized. Other times you come home wondering if you’re good enough. I wonder what you make of that.”
“I don’t know.”
“You don’t have to figure it out tonight.”
Denise stopped there. She didn’t campaign against Isabelle. She didn’t build a case. She didn’t try to persuade Cassy to dump her friend. Instead, over the next few months she continued asking thoughtful questions. What felt good? What didn’t? What did you notice about yourself? Gradually Cassy began making observations her mother never could have talked her into: I don’t like who I become around her; I always feel like I’m trying to impress her; I don’t think I trust her.
Those insights belonged to Cassy, and because they were hers, they had the power to change the friendship. Denise hadn’t solved middle school friendships, but she had done something just as important. She had made it more likely that Cassy would continue thinking with her about friendships.
Bottom line
Parents often ask me what to say and how to say it. After all these years, I think the better question is: What part of me does my child need me to bring forward right now?
Each parent is tending different soil. Limits, consequences and firm guidance have a better chance of taking root when the ground has already been enriched by respect, understanding and trust. That is good garden tending.
Children grow through many conversations. These conversations don’t determine who children become. Temperament, life experiences, relationships, culture and countless other influences all shape development. But when parents repeatedly discuss difficult issues with respect, curiosity, honesty and warmth, those conversations become part of the foundation children draw upon as they gradually build their own navigational system — one that helps them decide what is healthy, safe, wise and consistent with the person they are becoming.
The ultimate test of a good conversation about difficult matters isn’t whether you resolved the problem that day. It’s whether your child trusts you enough to come back for another one.
