My granddaughter, Ariella, has always adored books, much to her
family's delight. After all, we're told, you can never read enough to
your children. "Duck!" "Car!" "Birdie!" she'd exclaim, and point to the
bright, colorful pictures in a soft-cloth reader. She's learning words
and recognizing objects, I'd say to myself and anyone else who would
listen. Reading's working!
When I discovered computer software that helped hone some of those very
same skills, I was elated. So was she: "Truck!" "Cat!" "Doggie!" And
there they were on the screen -- colossal, crystal clear and often
accompanied by serene yet authoritative voices, thanks to my oversized
iMac LCD and reasonably up-to-date external audio speakers.
The thrill didn't last long (does it ever?): The naysayers were just
around the corner, ready to pounce on us overly permissive grown-ups
who let children use computers. The American Academy of Pediatrics, in
fact, recommends no screen time for children under age 2.
What's a parent to do? More to the point, what's a grandma to do?
Think moderation, education experts suggest. Expose kids to a whole
host of experiences. "Young children are little sponges," says Donna
Stanger, former general manager of Edmark, which develops educational
software. "Anything that enriches the child's environment and is
interactive is a good thing."
That includes computer use -- if you chose your software with care,
says Alice Baggett, technology teacher at Seattle Country Day School.
"We tend to be suspicious of technology," she says. "With so many
changes, there are risks that occur. But a smart population can figure
out how to use new technology well."
Pete Findley is CEO of Giant Campus, a Seattle-based company that
teaches tech skills to kids and adults. "The most important thing is to
focus on balance -- and kids who spend all their time in front of a
computer don't have a good balance," he says. "But technology skills
are important as reading and writing, and that's not going to go away.
It's part of life and second nature to today's kids. You have to
Embracing that can provide young students with "wonderful problem-
solving opportunities," Baggett notes. "Using computers involves risk
taking, as in, which button should I push? What will happen? And
there's learning to interact with a whole other language. The
technology introduces logical thinking in a new medium -- and that's
According to Baggett, the best software -- often offered in the
classroom -- helps kids learn to problem-solve, and capitalizes on
their creativity. "In an educational setting, the teacher can do
projects of greater complexity," she says. "At home, we're not always
there sitting with them and giving them help. With more sophisticated
software, kids can become the creators rather than the consumers."
Baggett's students create art using paint programs, use movie software
to make movies, play games to learn about the solar system, and learn
how to build three-dimensional models.
When parents select software for their children, they should target
programs that encourage perseverance, Stanger says. "One of the most
important things you can teach a child is that persistence pays off,"
she says. "We've found that if a child persists, the chance of solving
a problem is much greater."
Stanger also recommends that parents:
- Think about what you value and believe your child needs. Does the software provide that?
- Choose software that allows the child to think -- or to do something he or she couldn't do with paper and pencil.
software that supports an area that your child is not as strong in --
and pay attention to the way the software interacts with your child.
Millie's Math House, for example, keeps the child on task and rewards
the child for a correct answer.
sure the child has to do something to cause something to happen.
Software should be interactive. You don't want your child to click and
watch a movie go by.
granddaughter (she's now 4) was a little over a year old when we
sacrificed the blocks and the books for an occasional hour or so to
follow trucks and kitties floating impressively life-like across the
monitor. Is that too early for quality screen time?
Stanger won't commit. "It's like saying my 1-year-old and yours are all
the same," she says. "But I've seen a baby use a program where you
touch a key and something happens. And to sit on a parent or
grandparent's lap and laugh together -- I don't think that's so bad."
Linda Morganwrites frequently on education issues for ParentMap.
Alice Baggett's software picks:
- My favorite software to teach with is most definitely Microworlds Junior.
- I also really like Stagecast Creator.
- Kidpix is a wonderful introduction to how tools work-what the language of computers is and how the language works.
- I also like software from these companies: www.tomsnyder.com, and www.sunburst.com (formerly Edmark).
Here's a list of kids' software recommended by the Boston Museum of Science.
- Alice in Vivaldi's Four Seasons
Ages 5 and up
Music Games International, 2003
- Badger Trails
Sherston Software (Tool Factory), 2003
- Blue's 123 Time Activities
Ages 3 to 6
Humongous Entertainment (Atari), 1999
- Blue's Reading Time Activities
Ages 3 to 6
Humongous Entertainment (Atari), 2000
- Caillou: Magic Playhouse
Ages 2 to 6
The Learning Company (Riverdeep), 2001
- Click and Create with Mia
Ages 5 and up
Kutoka Interactive, 2002
- Curious George Downtown Adventure
Ages 3 to 6
Knowledge Adventure, 2002